This doctoral thesis shows that institutional evaluation policies fulfil a political function of non-electoral control of public actions in democratic systems, which so far has not been defined as such by the literature. It also argues for the need to study the performance of these policies from a democratizing perspective that problematizes the asymmetries that exist in the control of public policies and programs, between state and society. This proposition emerged from previous theoretical discussions about democracy and public control; program evaluation, evaluative policies and public policy analysis, and was subjected to empirical contrasts through a single qualitative case study of explanatory scope, focused on the Evaluation Policy of the Ministry of Social Development of Uruguay. From an analytical point of view, three models of “managerial bureaucratic and politicizing” control were established, which, as ideal types, evaluative policies can deploy. Furthermore, that this can be explained by observing the institutional conditions of a “normative, discursive and relational” type that these policies offer, at the three main levels of action at which they operate “micro, of the evaluative practices” they apply, “meso, of the programs evaluated” and “macro of the broader political environment”. Based on the case study, the research confirms that evaluation policies do indeed fulfil this control function. This can be seen in the creation of these policies, as a response to the need to improve the control of public actions; in their empirical deployment in the structures of public control involving state and social actors; and in the political interest aroused by their own control. Although in its beginnings, the policy studied promoted a politicizing control model with democratizing potential, after a few years and due to relational difficulties, this approach was called into question, giving way to a new discourse tending towards managerial control, on the basis of which new regulations were approved that consolidated this trend. In view of this evidence, and even though this policy has strengthened control within the government, it fails to make a democratizing contribution because it omits other state and social actors, who lack effective margins of control at the three levels analyzed.
Políticas institucionales de evaluación y control de acciones públicas. Un análisis neoinstitucional integrado sobre la Política de Evaluación del Ministerio de Desarrollo Social del Uruguay
Muñoz Mendoza, C. A. (Author). 6 Oct 2022
Student thesis: Doctoral thesis
Muñoz Mendoza, C. A. (Author),
Blanco Fillola, I. I. (Director),
6 Oct 2022Student thesis: Doctoral thesis
Student thesis: Doctoral thesis