Skip to main navigation Skip to search Skip to main content

Moving beyond modernization as a panacea: Pathways towards sustainable water use in community-based irrigation management

Student thesis: Doctoral thesis

Abstract

The modernization of irrigation systems, i.e., transforming traditional furrow into sprinkler or drip irrigation, increases the efficiency of water use in agriculture. On the one hand, such transformations augment the productivity of water and can therefore boost agricultural production. On the other hand, they are expected to conserve water for environmental functions, which are progressively jeopardized by growing water scarcity and climate change. However, considerable empirical evidence suggests that modernizing irrigation systems induces higher water consumption rates than prior, endangering the goal of sustainable water use in agriculture. This thesis addresses the issue by studying conditions under which modernization in contexts of community-based irrigation systems can contribute to more sustainable water use. Theoretically building on institutional economics and common pool resource theory, it contributes to better understanding how collective irrigation management and water use decisions are permeated by the uptake of modern irrigation technologies. Chapter 1 introduces the thesis by embedding it in its relevant context, describing the state of the art, outlining the research gaps, and formulating the main and sub-research questions. Chapter 2 employs a meta-analysis of case studies to identify distinct strategic decision-making situations and their interrelatedness with infrastructure modernization. Chapter 3 assesses the role of modernization among other conditions for successful drought management in Spanish water user associations. Chapter 4 presents a behavioral perspective on the effects of infrastructure modernization by examining whether farmers hold mental accounts depending on how they obtain water. Finally, chapter 5 concludes and ends with practical implications and an outlook on future research.
Date of Award1 Dec 2023
Original languageEnglish
SupervisorSergio Villamayor Tomas (Director)

Cite this

'