When talking about scientific models we have to explain what they mean and which their scope is. The diversity of uses leads us to question about the possibility of a unifying conception. Although we often consider formal and empirical cases different in nature, we can see that a characterization in terms of representation is wide enough to explain both possibilities. It is, in any case, an intentional and operative representation which allows us to distinguish them from the more general symbolic uses. Anyway, a notion of this kind allows us to consider the ontological attributions of a scientific theory also as a model so that we can propose a new type, the ontological one. If we accept this idea, we can see several implications. First of all, as we see when we study the case of relativistic geometry, we can associate different ontologies to the same theoretical formalization so we have to consider philosophically more convenient to understand them also as different theories. If we accept this characterization of theories as correct, we can analyze its contribution to the concept of scientific explanation and also consider it a new element in the discussion about the possibility of theories empirically equivalent. Indeed, as the ontological models establish which is the nature of theoretical entities with no translation to empirical principles and laws the differences between them are not sensible to observations so we have to admit, in fact, that they are not the same theory but empirically equivalent. Finally, by incorporating this concept model we will see if we have any criteria left in order to choose among these equivalent theories under a realistic perspective. We can formulate, for example, a criteria on ontological reduction based on a principle of the Unity of the World. This possibility does not suffer the disadvantages of other methods of reduction as formal or methodological ones and is based on the principle of independence of the world, which much easier to accept than the epistemological realism.
| Date of Award | 17 Jun 2017 |
|---|
| Original language | Catalan |
|---|
| Supervisor | Victor Gomez Pin (Director) |
|---|
- Scientific models
- Ontology
- Empirical equivalence
Models ontològics i teories equivalents
Jaime Pedro, R. R. (Author). 17 Jun 2017
Student thesis: Doctoral thesis
Jaime Pedro, R. R. (Author), Gomez Pin, V. (Director),
17 Jun 2017Student thesis: Doctoral thesis
Student thesis: Doctoral thesis