Skip to main navigation Skip to search Skip to main content

A Systems Approach in Ocean Governance: Values & Visions for Marine Planning - Case Studies in the Arctic and Mediterranean

Student thesis: Doctoral thesis

Abstract

Marine areas worldwide are increasingly contested spaces where various interests and activities take place necessitating robust governance and planning frameworks that incorporate diverse values and visions for sustainable futures. This dissertation addresses the complexities of marine and coastal planning through case studies in a remote coastal community in Northeastern Iceland and a transboundary sanctuary for marine mammals in the Mediterranean between Italy, France and the Principality of Monaco. The research highlights value pluralities and management horizons for effective marine planning, especially in the contexts of global tourism and marine mammal conservation with a focus on cetaceans. The primary research objectives focus on identifying and defining the values that local actors consider important for future marine and coastal planning, exploring how international tourists' values and behavioral insights can inform ethical tourism management, and elucidating the values of institutional and business stakeholders involved in marine activities. Addressing these aspects emphasizes the need for a valuation framework that advocates for a holistic approach including socio-cultural and ecological aspects as well as contextually salient dimensions. Empirical findings from qualitative interviews reveal a diverse spectrum of values, including the value of a healthy ecosystem, tourism sustainability, the well-being of whales, and cooperation and coordinated management across borders. This aligns with contemporary calls for more inclusive and equitable management regimes, particularly considering Iceland's recent marine planning legislation and ongoing discussions about area-based management tools. The research highlights the critical role of procedural justice in MSP, especially in the Arctic, where marine planning initiatives are still emerging. By examining the values of local communities and tourists in Húsavík, this study contributes to both the theoretical and practical realms of MSP, emphasizing the interconnectedness of human and nonhuman dimensions within socio-ecological systems. The study of the Pelagos Sanctuary for Marine Mammals further emphasizes the importance of institutional and business values and practices in marine regimes. This dissertation advances avenues for transformative governance systems that support the preservation and regeneration of marine habitats and value-inclusive approach essential for achieving sustainable and just outcomes in marine governance.
Date of Award12 Sept 2024
Original languageEnglish
SupervisorEduardo Ariza Sole (Director)

Cite this

'